HDL

http://wtfismygearscore.com/ so no need to install the addon.

Going down our top geared toons according to wow-heroes:

Undedpreest is 5709
Ranadae is 5610
Goull is 5571
Tenris is 5539
Tarnn is 5709
Acree is 5515
Skippy is 5631

Vitandus is a lowly 5376

Prime example how gear score does not equate to performance:

Muffnman, 5672.

How do we know whether Tarnn or Undedpreest is better???   ??? :( :( ???

Quote from: Faraherde on Wed, 2010-02-24 : 14:27
How do we know whether Tarnn or Undedpreest is better???   ??? :( :( ???

Tarnn is WAY better.  Just look at all those achievement points.

Quote from: Faraherde on Wed, 2010-02-24 : 14:27
How do we know whether Tarnn or Undedpreest is better???   ??? :( :( ???

"Have them fight."

I will say I healing Undedpreest (as his rogue) while he was tanking heroic nexus.  Agro on one mob wasn't a problem, but he really can't keep AoE threat like Tarnn can.  I had to use STONECLAW TOTEM to help proect myself.  Once the other rogue started using tricks on him and AoEing, there were better.  In addition, he requires far more healing on a boss (big tree one for example) than Tarnn does. 

So while he can tank, it's not like Tarnn.  So Tarnn is better from a mitigation and agro standpoint.

The real question is, what is better?  A Troll or a Rogue?

Oh yes, and you should get the mod =)

QuoteThe real question is, what is better?  A Troll or a Rogue?

Hrusk.  He's both.

Quote from: Vitandus on Wed, 2010-02-24 : 14:18
Prime example how gear score does not equate to performance:

Muffnman, 5672.

I was quite surprised when I saw this, also in the welcome message in vent, only because last week someone randomly who I do not know told me never to run anything with him because apparently he ninjas loot for his wife or something in raids? I dont know, but i thought it was funny.  :D

If the fight is less then 30 seconds and mostly physical damage I am a far superior tank then Tarnn.

Hi guys, tis me  :P

And...

Quote from: Puddiin on Thu, 2010-02-25 : 08:11

Quote from: Vitandus on Wed, 2010-02-24 : 14:18
Prime example how gear score does not equate to performance:

Muffnman, 5672.

I was quite surprised when I saw this, also in the welcome message in vent, only because last week someone randomly who I do not know told me never to run anything with him because apparently he ninjas loot for his wife or something in raids? I dont know, but i thought it was funny.  :D

http://wtfismygearscore.com/gearscore.php?n=muffnman&s=Zul%27jin&r=US&refresh=Y

I'm anonymouse!